Award-winning GP wins ‘David and Goliath’ landmark legal battle against NHS England
Court of Appeal ruling has implications for thousands of NHS GPs and dentists involved in contractual disputes in future
An award-winning GP has today won a landmark five year legal battle with NHS England after his contract was unlawfully terminated in a complex dispute sparked by his refusal to join his local Primary Care Network and share confidential patient data.
Today’s Court of Appeal ruling in favour of Dr Sashi Shashikanth, has broad implications for all NHS GPs and dentists as it gives them the right to seek Judicial Review of decisions by the NHS Adjudicator if they end up in dispute with NHS England.
Previously, if the case went to an NHS Adjudicator, GPs and dentists had little legal redress if the case went against them or the decision was unlawful – as in Dr Shashikanth’s case.
Dr Shashikanth, who operates two practices with more than 8,200 patients in West London, said: “I would like to thank my legal team, the BMA, those who helped fund the case and everyone who has supported me through the last five extremely challenging years for believing in me and standing by me.
“While I am delighted to have won this legal challenge, in my view it should never have reached this stage and this long and bitter battle has taken a huge toll on me, not least financially.
“The whole saga is solely the result of unfortunate decisions taken by the former NHS Hillingdon Clinical Commissioning Group (CCG) when I refused to join the PCN or hand over, in my view illegally, wholesale confidential patient data to a private enterprise.
“I would urge the Health Secretary to take a very close look at this case which has unnecessarily cost the taxpayer hundreds of thousands of pounds at a time when other GP practices which refused to join their PCNs elsewhere in England have been operating successfully and reached local agreements.
“I would also urge NHS England to now fully support my two practices, so that we can provide any PCN services as well as enhanced services to our own patients, just as they have supported non PCN and non data sharing practices elsewhere. All we want is to be a family doctors’ practice which can continue to provide a personalised service to our own patients, which is something the Health Secretary Wes Streeting says he wants.”
The case centred on whether a letter in 2019 sent by the CCG to Dr Shashikanth had amounted to a valid contract variation, and thus obliged the GP principal to co-operate with the PCN.
Appeal Court judges ruled that the CCG had failed to give notice of a variation to Dr Shashikanth’s contract and the NHS Litigation Authority, now NHS Resolution, “erred in law in determining that the CCG were entitled to terminate the contracts”.
The British Medical Association (BMA) and the Londonwide Local Medical Committees(LLMC) also supported Dr Shashikanth’s legal challenge.
The long and bitter legal battle was sparked by Dr Shashikanth’s refusal, supported by legal advice and the wishes of his practice patients’ groups, to give access to all confidential patients’ data to a private enterprise running his local Primary Care Network.
As a result his contract was terminated by the Hillingdon Clinical Commissioning Group (CCG) which also lodged a series of unfounded complaints about the GP to a range of key bodies including NHS England’s performance management, the General Medical Council (GMC) and the Care Quality Commission (CQC), each of which rejected the complaints.
The local Labour MP John McDonnell took up the case, met with patients’ groups and raised it in parliament.
John Rogers, 80, a cancer patient who leads a local patients’ group, said: “The Court of Appeal ruling is absolutely the right decision and I’m delighted that at last the law has come through for Dr Shashikanth. This whole episode was sparked by what I can only describe as a vendetta against him by the previous CCG and I hope that those in charge now will put things right. There must be an inquiry.”
Dr Shashikanth’s legal team comprised Vikram Sachdeva KC and Jake Thorold, Essex Chambers; Admas Habteslasie, Landmark Chambers; and solicitor Stewart Duffy.
in a statement on their website, Mr Duffy, Legal Director at Weightmans LLP notes: “This case brings much needed clarity to the position of the majority of GP contract holders, and to others such as dentists, who hold ‘non-NHS’ contracts for the delivery of primary care services. The judgment makes clear that if such contractors refer a dispute to the NHS Dispute Resolution procedure they will not be powerless if the Adjudicator reaches an unlawful decision.”