Why most UK NDAs wouldn’t survive being challenged in court
Most NDAs sent between UK businesses have never been tested in court, which is probably a good thing, because a large number of them wouldn’t hold up.
The problem isn’t usually the confidentiality part. Protecting genuinely sensitive information, client lists, pricing, unreleased products, is something courts are generally comfortable enforcing. The problem is what gets bundled in alongside it. Most “NDAs” in circulation aren’t pure confidentiality agreements at all. They quietly include non-compete and non-solicit language, restricting who the other party can work with or work for after the relationship ends. That’s not confidentiality. That’s a restraint of trade, and UK courts treat it completely differently.
A restraint of trade clause is only enforceable if it goes no further than necessary to protect a legitimate business interest. Courts don’t ask whether the restriction is reasonable in general. They ask whether it’s reasonable for this specific situation, this role, this relationship. A non-compete that would be fine for a senior partner with client relationships is very likely too broad for a junior contractor with none.
This is where Tillman v Egon Zehnder Ltd [2019] UKSC 32 matters. The Supreme Court confirmed that if part of a restrictive clause is too wide, a court can strip out just the offending words and enforce what’s left, provided the rest of the clause still makes sense without them and doesn’t fundamentally change what it was restricting. This is known as the blue pencil test. It sounds like good news for whoever wrote the clause, but it isn’t something to rely on. Courts will use it to save a clause that’s mostly fine. They won’t rewrite a clause that’s fundamentally overreaching from the start.
Most people assume an NDA is either enforceable or it isn’t, all or nothing. In practice a court is far more likely to sever the unreasonable part and leave a weaker version standing, or strike the whole restrictive covenant out and leave the confidentiality terms intact.
For a business based in London, where NDAs get exchanged constantly before pitches, funding conversations and contractor engagements, the practical fix is to stop treating “NDA” as one document that does everything. Keep confidentiality obligations tightly scoped to actual sensitive information, and if you need a non-compete or non-solicit on top, write it separately, time-limit it, and geographically or contractually limit it to what the relationship actually justifies.
If you’ve got a standard NDA template you send to everyone regardless of seniority or role, that’s the clause most likely to fail if it’s ever tested. Narrow it before you need to rely on it, not after.
Irfan Dadabhai is the founder of LexPact (lexpact.co.uk), an AI contract platform that generates UK NDAs, Terms of Business and freelance agreements built around the statutes and case law that actually apply to them.